英國和美國讀會計degree的分別

2010-06-05 9:14 pm
我係英國讀左幾年書,讀到second year fail左,學校offer我轉去讀top-up degree, 不過呢個course 冇我想讀既audit, 同埋冇會計師考試既examption, 但係因為fail左,所以得唔到其他學校既offer, 而我冇考慮repeat 因為學校太貴.

另一方面,我朋友介紹我到美國的BYU hawaii讀書, 呢個course 有我想讀既modules, 但係我擔心美國既degree比英國難讀和我打算將來在英國或者香港做會計師, 如果去美國讀就會拎唔到visa返英國, 同埋美國讀完去考英國既ICAEW可能會唔承認.

1)英國同美國既會計課程學術上會否有很大既分別?

2)
i)美國和英國學位既認受性在香港和英國的情況
ii)持美國degree返英國找工作會否很困難

3)如果我要考ICAEW/ACCA/QP, 個degree對個試有冇影響?

UK: i) 個course冇aduit, 如果考QP果d冇學過會好難pass
ii)Top-up degree (考會計師試是否一定要有正統既學位?)

US: i)美國degree可否去報考英國的ICAEW/ACCA?


請大家比d意見, THANKS!!

回答 (2)

2010-06-06 5:53 pm
✔ 最佳答案
I want to say this outright, unless you plan on getting the Practics Accountant ALL the way, it is not good to study in one place, then try to get PA in another.

IT WILL BE ALOT EASIER TO GET PA IN ONE PLACE FIRST, THEN MOVE

That is, if you want to study in US, you should get ACCA/AICPA member ship before going to UK for work.

If you want to get QP in UK, you better study all the way in the UK.

1)英國同美國既會計課程學術上會否有很大既分別?

NO, unlike gary's said, ONLY TAXATION/LAW is different (Which maybe 6 subjects), accounting principle is the same.

i)美國和英國學位既認受性在香港和英國的情況
ii)持美國degree返英國找工作會否很困難

i) HK WILL NOT REGONISE ANY DEGREE, they only regonise if you can pass the HKICPA/QP qualification, if you can pass them they won't care about your degree, even if your degree is from angola.

ii) You cannot work unless you either have AICPA/ACCA/QP qualification in the UK, it is not about your degree, but professional regonition

3)如果我要考ICAEW/ACCA/QP, 個degree對個試有冇影響?

Yes, you may need to have some bridging course done if you waish to use oversea qualification to claim local Professional Accountant Membership


UK i) Any degree without auditing is NOT a Professional Degree, so you should not be able to get QP done.

ii) Yes, a Professional Accountant must have a Professional Accounting Degree, which the local Assessment authority regonise as a Professional Accounting degree.

US i) You cannot take QP directly when you have a US Degree, the law and taxation Would be different, you must finish a master course or a bridging course beforeyo ucan get QP.



參考: My Mother is a CPAA, and my wife is a AICPA member
2010-06-06 11:16 am
1. Yes because U.K. and U.S. are using different accounting principals.

2. Since HKICPA follows British styles, so American degree will not be as good as U.K. or Hong Kong degree (as bridging programs may be required). Also, currently HKICPA does not recognize CPA accredited by AICPA. So it is still a doubt that if you can practice.

3. Yes. See above.


收錄日期: 2021-04-24 07:55:25
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100605000051KK00607

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份