光可推動鏡子嗎

2010-02-08 9:13 pm
感謝8801physics君,讓我知道photon雖然沒有mass,但也有momentum。

現有一個想像中的實驗:
假設有一面完美的鏡,能百分百反射光,不會有energy loss。
鏡垂直安裝在一架滑輪車上,滑輪車也是完美,沒有friction。
問題,如果我用電筒射向鏡子,光子的momentum是否理論上可令滑輪車和鏡子前進?
更新1:

nvieky, 外動力不必大過物體的重量才可推動物體。 例如我是65kg,但我可以推動一輛1000kg的汽車。 如果汽車沒有friction,理論上一隻手指也可以推動汽車。

更新2:

我說的實驗可用另一個問法: 一粒光子photon射在鏡上,反彈時的一刻,光子有沒有一個force加在鏡上?

回答 (3)

2010-02-09 4:54 am
✔ 最佳答案
Yes, this theory works. In fact, it is the theory of "photon pressure" or "radiation pressure"

The change of momentum of a photon when reflected from a surface indeed gives rise to an impulse to the surface. If the surface is large and there are quite a large number of photons hitting the surface in a unit time. This could provide a propulsion for space travel.

Suppose there are n number of photons, each of which with energy E, hitting a flat surface with area A in a unit time.

since momentum of photon p = E/c, where c is the speed of light
The change of momentum of a photon if it is reflected = 2p = 2E/c
hence, the total change of momentum in 1 second if all photons are reflected = 2nE/c
The force given by the photons on the surface F= 2nE/c
or the pressure exerted onto the surface by the incident photons
= 2nE/Ac

Therefore, if n is sufficient large (i.e. a large surface area is used so as to 'catch' a large number of photons), the force F could be good enough to propel a small spacecraft to move in space under an acceleration.

In fact, such principle has already been used in the design of "solar sails" that makes use of photons coming from the sun to propel sapcecrafts.

You may wish to look at the following interesting article about solar sail. There is also a calculation showing how an acceleration as high as 9 m/s2 (almost equal to that of the acceleration due to gravity) could be achieved on a small 1 kg spacecraft.

http://www.howstuffworks.com/solarsail.htm/printable

2011-11-26 5:07 am
I have found an interesting web-page. you may wish to take a look !

http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E8%BC%BB%E5%B0%84%E5%A3%93
2010-02-08 10:54 pm
不可能的,因為鏡子和滑輪車都是一件物體而物體皆有其重量的,它們不可能像無重狀態懸浮在空間上的,就算是也有1n地深吸力附著,外動力大過物體重量+1n才可推動得到物件的。


收錄日期: 2021-04-29 17:35:48
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100208000051KK00541

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份