1. A student collected samples of two minerals – X and Y. Both minerals are colourless and crystalline, though Y is obviously mixed with small amounts of a reddish brown solid. X is insoluble in water while Y is almost completely soluble. The following table shows the results of tests conducted on X and Y.
Test
Description
Observations
I
Flame test
X gave a dull red flame colour.
Y gave a yellow flame colour.
II
X was added to dilute hydrochloric acid
X dissolved in dilute hydrochloric acid with the evolution of a gas that turned limewater milky.
III
Dilute nitric acid was added to a solution of Y, followed by silver nitrate solution
A white precipitate formed.
a) The reddish brown solid mixed with Y is insoluble in water. Suggest how you would show that it contains iron(III) ion.