NL rookie of the year?

I knwo know why you ranked Coghlan over McCutchen, he beats McCutchen by only a few batting average points. But McCutchen pretty much beats him in ever other stat.

And also im a lil iffy about putting Hansen number 2 and leaving wells so low. Both have the same amount of wins, but Wells actually have the better ERA and WHIP.

J.A. Happ.

Colby hands down

andrew mccutchen

I am going to pick Hanson. There are a lot of good rookies up there. Hanson has come up and pitched very well for the Braves. He came up around the end of May if memory serves me correct.

happ definitely. he has more wins than most other starters, and he hasnt been in the rotation for the whole year, and lidge is his closer (has blown wins for happ)

2 shutouts, come one

mccutchen impresses me almost as much

Its a pretty weak class this year, but I agree with Pakli1988, gotta go with J.A. Happ (as much as it pains me. I didn't even realize he qualified.) He had 31.2 innings last year, need to be at 50 innings or under to be classified as a rookie:

This year (2009):
10-3, 2.63, 3 CG (2 SO), great BAA .226

Tommy Hanson of the Atlanta Braves and Garrett Jones of the Pittsburgh Pirates are my top 2 right now,and Kyle Blanks and Everth Cabrera have had great seasons,but they aren't as publicized as the other two since they play in San Diego. Also,has been great since the Jake Peavy trade.

happ will not win it because he pitched a bit last year and what's more impressive is hanson's performance after coming up midseason. i do get to see happ at the bank on wensday tho so that may influence me.

rasmus had it until holliday, garret jones is decent but iut was mostly a hot week, wels has been spectacular, coghlan has gotten hot of late, but mccutchen is in second for me. that guy can rake man.

Colby Rasmus.