Which player is worse?

Obviously the guy that homers. but .255 isn't that bad if he has a good OBP an contibutes in the field.

Brandon Inge is the first choice right? Go with the power, than the slight increase in BA

The baseballer with more home runs is better.

It all depends when the second player has his hits, because if they are clutch hits, i'd rather have him, but it looks like your talking about carlos pena, and he is a pretty clutch hitter, so on my team i would much rather have the first player, because he contributes a lot in runs, rbis, and HR's.

Aramis Ramirez, Derrek Lee, and Alfonso Soriano.

a player that hits 215 and hits 25 home runs because i think you're talking about carlos pena but more homers