Grammar question, please help?

2009-08-18 12:36 pm
Does "which" in the middle of a sentence, refer to a sentence or a particular noun?

e.g.
This is the first time for me to write a letter in English, which is exciting.

Does "which" refer to the entire first sentence
"This is the first time for me to write a letter in English", or just the noun "time"?

Thank you very much!

回答 (3)

2009-08-22 6:37 am
✔ 最佳答案
"which" actually refers to the last independent noun in a sentence. In this case, it refers to the "letter." (English is in a prepositional phrase dependent on "letter").

The sentence is not grammatical unless you're saying the letter is exciting. If you are trying to say that "time" is exciting, then you must say "This is the first time I'm writing a letter in English and it's exciting!" or a variant thereof.
參考: Grammarian and native speaker of English
2009-08-18 7:49 pm
Well you could look at it like this. You could say it and then ask yourself the question. "This is the first time for me to write a letter in English, which is exciting." Then someone could ask, "what's (which's) exciting?" Then you answer, "oh, writing a letter in English for the first time." Yeaah? Do you understand what I mean?

So, there you go, it pretty much refers to the sentence, or is it a clause?
參考: native english speaker
2009-08-18 7:40 pm
In that context, it would refer to "write a letter in English." Sometimes it could refer to a noun.


收錄日期: 2021-05-01 12:44:01
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090818043628AAn86KC

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份