I am an international student studying in London. I rent a house with my schoolmates in a one year contract. We've paid all the payment for the house. The below water leaking event happened not more than a month after we moved in.
In last Sept, there was a water leaking problem caused the fallen of bathroom ceiling. Only one tenant in the house at that moment. One night Mary (The tenant) back home after 1 week vacation, she discovered the ceiling dropped in the bathroom. She rang agent promptly. Barry (The plumber) came to re-build the water pipes which cost £150. Barry reported it was because the pipes were built too short caused the leakage. The landlord agreed to repair the pipes but rejected to repair the ceiling. Since the landlord was not in London he requested Mary to settle the repair charge of the pipes first and promised will return her the money.
On 7 April this year, we received an email from the landlord suddenly ask us to pay £500 to repair the ceiling. He said the plumber told him it takes 2 weeks for a water leakage lead to the fallen ceiling. The landlord claimed that Mary had neglected the water leakage and should have tell them before the ceiling dropped down. It is unbelievable to say that the cause of the broken ceiling was the tenant since we were the one suffered. We believe that the landlord is denying his legal responsibility and trying to take advantage from us. It had been 5 months after the event happened, if he claims that it was our problem he should had raised this question at 5 months ago before he promised that he would settle the repair charge. It is supposed that the landlords have insurance plan for their house. We couldn't understand his aim and would like to ask for help and advices.
Who should be responsible for the repair?
How is the landlord's personality and what is he trying to do?
What action should we do?
Does the landlord have rights to kick us out if we refuse to his demand?