甘告唔告得入非禮罪

2009-04-01 6:59 am
我系扶手上整衣服及袋時不小心掂左一位小姐既腳!
距就我摸距隻腳,依家話要告我!只系掂一掂 無心之失!其實當時有無掂到咪我自己都感覺唔到!
當時系無第3者同cctv都睇唔到!
我系警署d 啊sir都話我系有心!仲講晒粗口
我想問甘告我入罪機會大唔大?
第一次上庭系唔系只講認唔認罪?
更新1:

無掂到我自己都唔知!就算系有掂到都系1-2秒時間!系距令轉面大聲講你做咩!我就以為自己頭先個動作掂到距!好自由甘講左聲對唔住,距就捉住我大叫非禮! 但距系我話摸距!距對警察話feel到有人摸距!

回答 (4)

2009-04-01 7:18 am
✔ 最佳答案
只要你真係無心,咁就唔構成非禮

刑事法有假定,要求被告有犯罪意圖才可定罪 (presumption of mens rea)。你無心既話,就無mens rea,就唔會有刑事責任

英國案例 Regina v. Court [1988] 2 WLR 1071 列明,非禮需符合三點:
1. 被告刻意對受害人作身體接觸
2. 客觀猥褻:該行為對一般人來說,屬猥褻
3. 主觀猥褻:被告刻意作出如此猥褻之行

系扶手上整衣服及袋時不小心掂左一位小姐既腳,符合唔到第1、3點,第2點都可以拗下,所以應該不構成非禮

當然,你必須要法官信納你的口供,如果你話自己無心但法官唔信,而控方能證明你有心,咁樣你都會被定罪。如果你點人地點左好耐都唔縮手,邊個會信你不小心 。

如果真係無心,第一堂就一定唔好認,亦唔好對差佬認,搵律師幫你。刑事案既舉證責任在控方,控方要入你罪要排除合理疑點,證明以上3點,有律師幫你唔會容易告得入。

千祈唔好因為依d案刑罰輕而認罪~案底跟一世架!
2009-04-01 8:00 am
有無掂到我自己都唔知!就算係有掂到都係1-2秒時間!係佢擰轉面大聲講你做咩!我就以為自己頭先個動作掂到佢!好自然咁講咗聲對唔住,佢就捉住我大叫非禮!
但佢係話我摸佢!佢對警察話feel到有人摸佢!
2009-04-01 7:35 am
Prosecution will rely on the witness statement, and the only witness will be the victim, the girl who complaint your touch. So virtually it will be your words against her. Normally the court should assume you are innocent, however, in real life, bias always put against the Defender.
therefore you better raise facts of the situation, for example is it a crowd place? you stand reaonably far away from the girl? your hand only touch the girl once when you tidying urself, you have not act strange at anytime. Also you can attack the girl's credibility, e.g. your hand touhed her or your clothes touched her, her statement match the scene description? she ID you? etc.

To the police, you better file a verbal assualt or harrasment against the one who swear at you, if he did actually yell, swear or act aggressively or oppressively, bear in mind the police probably be another prosecution witness act against you.
2009-04-01 7:19 am
講真,如果真係如你所講我都認為你好無辜!如果真係感都要搞到要上庭既話,感就要睇下你當時既舉動係點,如果你既動作係大又或者係綠低左你係望住個女人冇個部位既話就對你好不利,
而罪証方面希望有人或物件証明倒你係冇意,仲有,你係咪成隻手掌hi晒埋去個女仔度先,呢個非常重要,另外,如果你係police station果度比阿sir凶既話你可以問佢號碼,講真,阿sir爆粗唔岩你可以告佢,若果佢講既野直接令到你不安你直頭可以詔port佢,最後祝你好運.
參考: 自己

收錄日期: 2021-04-19 14:05:49
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090331000051KK01934

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份