very very in maths Q

2009-03-07 5:11 am
sqrt( x + 3sqrt(x + 1) ) = 3



x + 3sqrt(x + 1) = 9



3sqrt(x + 1) = 9 - x



9(x + 1) = 81 - 18x + x^2



x^2 - 27x + 72 = 0



(x - 3)(x - 24) = 0



x = 3 or x = 24



checking .....



when x = 3,



L.H.S. = sqrt( 3 + 3sqrt(3 + 1) ) = 3 = R.H.S.



when x = 24,



L.H.S. = sqrt( 24 + 3sqrt(24 + 1) ) = sqrt(39) not equal to R.H.S.



rejected



so, x = 3

Why a calculated value can be rejected
什麼時候要checking

回答 (3)

2009-03-14 9:21 am
✔ 最佳答案
sqrt( x + 3sqrt(x + 1) ) = 3 ==>x + 3sqrt(x + 1) = 9
ok 不需要 check 因為 確定 3>0

x + 3sqrt(x + 1) = 9==>3sqrt(x + 1) = 9 - x
ok 移項不會產生問題

3sqrt(x + 1) = 9 - x==>9(x + 1) = 81 - 18x + x^2
平方可能產生重根需要check

9(x + 1) = 81 - 18x + x^2==>x^2 - 27x + 72 = 0
ok 移項不會產生問題

x^2 - 27x + 72 = 0==>(x - 3)(x - 24) = 0
ok 因式分解不會產生問題

(x - 3)(x - 24) = 0==>x = 3 or x = 24
ok


x=-3 ==>x^2=9 不能亂平方,為解題需要平方就要check

x^2-9=0
(x+3)(x-3)=0
so x=3 or x=-3
2009-03-07 5:26 am
why do u need to check ?

since u changed the original equation to a quadratic equation and used the skill of quadratic equation to solve the problem.
hence, 3 and 24 are only the roots of x^2 - 27x + 72 = 0,
but not both of them can satisfy the original question {sqrt( x + 3sqrt(x + 1) ) = 3}. remember that the original question is not a quadratic equation.

so u need to check which one cant satisfy or if both of them can.
For those question with sqroot, fraction, log and so forth
u need to pay attention.


for thosesqroot questions, there cant be a negative number inside the sqroot
for those fraction questions, denominator cant equal zero
for those log problem, again there cant be a negative number inside log
2009-03-07 5:15 am
當數字出現 x^1 和開方根號x 同時出現的時候


收錄日期: 2021-04-13 16:29:20
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090306000051KK01572

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份