English Question

樓上個個錯到離譜
係個文法/時間上既問題

the difference is on the "time"
rather if it's past tense or past perfect
notice have/been and did/go

口語上有少少分別
"where did you go" 通常係"你(那個時候)去左邊"
而 "where have you been" 有"你去過邊度(時間比較長)"

其實have/been
有comparison, 即係對比
理論上, 當你有兩件事情既時候才可以用have/been
for example:
"did you ride a bike towards the store?"
"i have been riding a bike and i have finally got home."

因爲踩完單車, 先返oak kay
以上既對比就係時間上既對比

所以你條問題就gum問, 可以無太大分別, 但其實文法上是有的

我之前都有問過, 我個老師查左成個鐘頭字典
之後再問埋研究拉丁文既老師 (英文係黎自拉丁)
再查英文grammar書先知道咋

很多唔係大學修英文的都晤太知
你唔明的話是正常的
只是給你一個印象而已:)

where have you been：你要去邊？
where did you go：你去左邊到呀？

are they not the same thing?