有關神父非禮案中受害人能否上天堂

2009-01-28 8:26 pm
若有青年遭到同性神父非禮、雞姦,該青年是否等同進行同性戀行為,日後會否影響上天堂的機會?
若該青年事後放棄返教會,上帝是否不容許的?他會否因為不虔誠而上不到天堂?上帝給這個考驗予一名年僅十五歲的青年,是否有點過火?
若該青年因為這此經歷引致性取向扭曲,喜歡男性,然而他仍然繼續信教,上帝又會否容許他上天堂?
若他不能上天堂,那假使「一切已有安排」,是否上帝一早已安排這名青年不能上天堂?(因一般男性十分抗拒被同性侵犯,更莫論是一名正處於自我認識階段的青年)

回答 (3)

2009-01-31 10:45 pm
✔ 最佳答案
I think :

1. The priest has set up a very bad example for other people. The priest is not faithful to God. However, the teenager (the victim) is not guilty (I think) because he does not commit crime on purpose.

2. God is lenient and he will not punish those who do not believe him. According to Catholic Faith, those 'who have no chances to recognise God' or those 'who refuse to recognise God due to bad behaviours of other people' are not guilty. Those people who set bad examples are guilty.

3. One must be faithful to God and always pray for a correct way of life. Though that experience is a sad one, the victim still can lead to a worthwhile and meaningful life.

4. God is just and fair. He is lenient for frank confession but severe punishments will be made on those who remain stubborn.

Hope the above can help you solve your problems.
參考: me,books,webpages
2009-03-04 8:29 pm
如果受害者有善良,良心的話
一定可以上天堂
哈哈
lala
神父一定受法律制裁
2009-02-04 9:02 pm
上帝按着“自己的形像”造人, 並賦予人自由的意志。(創世記1:27) 如果人要懷着愛心去尊榮事奉上帝, 而非像機械人似的, 一舉一動都已預先決定, 自由意志就是不可或缺的了。 聰慧、 自由的受造物對上帝所表現的愛心使他能够反駁不公平的指控。 上帝説: “我兒, 你要作智慧人, 好叫我的心歡喜, 使我可以回答那譏誚我的人。”箴言27:11。

如果上帝僕人的際遇是預定的, 彷彿預先制定的程式一般, 他們對造物主的愛有多真摯豈不會受人質疑嗎? 上帝若不考慮到人本身的功過, 就預先選定一些人去享榮耀和快樂, 這豈不與他的大公無私背道而馳嗎? 再者, 如果有些人受到這樣優待, 其他人則注定要受永刑, 這就很難從“蒙選召的人”引發感恩之心了。創世記1:27; 約伯記1:8; 使徒行傳10:34,35。


收錄日期: 2021-04-13 16:23:20
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090128000051KK00460

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份