我唔識分幾時用past perfect 同past tence呀!!!

2008-09-02 7:04 am
呢句ge話應該係用past tence
this summer, Although I didn’t do many things, I had experienced many different kinds of things.

定係past perfect呀?
this summer, Although I had not done many things, I experienced many different kinds of things.


這句先岩?
更新1:

定係剩用past tence呀? 講下俾我聽點分呀! thanks!!!!!

回答 (3)

2008-09-02 8:33 am
✔ 最佳答案
Present perfect tense - Talking about an action in the past :
- But the time is neither unimportant nor not mentioned.
- Example : I have gone to Japan before (we do not know when from the sentence)
-
- But the action still has influence now.
- Example : It has been raining heavily this morning so all the roads are still wet. – Meaning : although the rain stops, the roads are still wet.
-
- But the action still has not finished now.
- Example : I has been raining heavily since this morning (still raining now)
-
- Talk about an action that you expect to happen but it finally did not happen.
- Example : John has not come. (But you expect that he would come).

So, for your sentence, you can look at the above definition of present perfect tense and see whether your sentence belongs to anyone of the examples.

The answer is no. Therefore, you just need to use simple past tense :

This summer, although I did not do many things, I experienced many different kinds of things.

You do not need to use past perfect tense “had experienced” because you do not have 2 actions happened in the past and you need to tell us which one comes first.
參考: Myself
2008-09-02 8:08 pm
This summer, although I did not do many things, I experienced many different kinds of things.
這句用過去式是正確的,無須用過去完成式,因為兩件事是同時發生的,沒有那件是先或後的因素。又因為 this summer 其實是很貼近現在的回想,所以這句用現在完成式也可。

This summer, although I have not done many things, I have experienced many different kinds of things.

過去完成式只表示一件事是發生在另一件過去的事之前。

現實中其實很少用過去完成式,因用連接詞或時間副詞已可表示兩件事的發生時間的先後,如:

I made a reply call to him after he called me but to no avail.
' after ' 已清楚表示是他先來電找我,先後次序清楚明確,根本不需用過去完成式表示他先來電這個動作。
or He called me but to no avail. Then I made a reply call to him.
2008-09-02 8:24 am
「this summer, Although I didn't do many things, I have experienced many different kinds of things.」呢句岩些﹐後面那句用present perfect tense好點。

past tense 係指那個動作已經過去了﹐但冇明確表明那動作是否已經「完成」。
past perfect tense 係指那個動作是在「過去」時已經完成了。
另外﹐present perfect tense 係指那個動作從過去開始進行﹐到目前為止仍然進行 或 到目前為止剛好完成。
參考: 自己


收錄日期: 2021-04-19 01:48:19
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080901000051KK02697

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份