What is American people's view towards Marxism?

2007-12-28 4:28 am
I am a Chinese student,
I want to know what does a common Americn's view towards Marxism and Communism is.
Our text book is of course always speaking highly of our regime,
while I'm still confused about what is other peoples' opinion towars it.
Please give me a short introduction in this topic,
to tell me some of your thoughts.
Maybe you can give me some pictures of American high school students' textbooks.
Much thanks! Sincerely!!

My email is
[email protected]

Thank you for your help again!

PS. I'm also an English learner,
so would you please tell me whether there is any mistakes in those sentenses above?

回答 (3)

2007-12-28 7:15 am
✔ 最佳答案
I resent "teacher" Lee's statements that Americans are ignorant of Marxism and Communism. On the contrary, I (and many others that I know) are quite familiar with the concept(s).

The original ideal behind Marxism had some merit. However, the biggest failing in the theory is that it failed to take into account human nature.

Marx' quote "From each according to his ability, to each according to his need" (Critique) sounds great! But humanity is, by nature, competitive and greedy and therefore, it doesn't work.

Under Marxist theory, people are also supposed to be the same -- but that will not happen either.

I challenge you to look at your own country! Do you see party officials with more privileges than others? Can some people drive cars and not others?

That is not to say that Capitalism is the answer either. However, capitalism does pander to human nature and at least does it openly. It recognizes basic human greed and competitiveness.

Communism has also failed in almost every country. The Soviet Union fell apart; your own country is embracing capitalism. I think about the only "true" communist countries left would be Cuba and North Korea.

So ... a "common" American's view of Marxism. Hope it helps!
2007-12-28 3:44 pm
Beth expressed it very well./
2007-12-28 4:54 am
Hello, I am an English Teacher from London. I have corrected your question as follows:

I am a Chinese student. I want to know what the commonly held American views towards Marxism and Communism are?
Our text books of course always speak highly of our regime,
but I'm still confused about what other peoples' opinion about it may be.
Please give me a short introduction on this topic and tell me some of your thoughts.
Perhaps you could also send me some pictures of American high school students' textbooks.
Many thanks! Yours sincerely!!

As for Americans views towards Marxism and Communism - from my experience most of them are completely ignorant of the subjects.


收錄日期: 2021-04-25 13:25:15
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20071227202850AAGTM8T

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份