當年日本侵華事件,日本天皇應該要付上責任嗎?

2007-12-14 1:52 am
當時發動侵華時,日本天皇是否知情?為何當時二次大戰結束後,為何日本天皇可以免除死刑?
當時天皇發動侵華戰爭,令很多中國人無辜被日軍殺死,天皇應該好像東條英機一樣,判定死刑.,居然天皇可以免死,天理何在呀!
現在事情已經發生了70年,事件證據確鑿,日本境然不承認侵華事實,還一口咬定自己國家是受害者,認為美國是侵略者.
日本居然歪曲事實,否認侵華事件,其實如果美國沒有投下原子彈的話,日本有沒有可能會投降?
其實當時美國向廣島,長崎市投下原子彈,美國這樣做是否正確?
因為美國所投下的傷亡人數,也是手無寸鐵的平民百姓.
以前天皇始終沒有承認,現在日本皇族的後裔是否要承認侵華責任?
(其實我認為日皇天皇應該要被軍事法庭受審判,我不想他可以安詳地死去)

回答 (3)

2007-12-18 1:27 am
✔ 最佳答案
If USA did not drow 2 atomic bombs to Hirosuma and nagasaki, I think the Japanese Empire would not surrender, because during the end of WWII, the emperor said they would offend untill the last Japanese died, that is 一億玉碎. After the war, the US army collected many weapons from the local unit. So 一億玉碎 was not a lie. If US tried to defeat Japan by landing the mainalnd of Japan, US would pay a heavy cost for Japanese surrender.
That's why we can conclude that the decision of dropping atomic bombs was a must. If not, more people would be suffered. Not only the American, but also japanese mass.

The Emperor obviously knew the plan of invasion, as that was 田中奏摺. However, I criticized whether he could stop the militarymen to start the war as the militarymen had already controlled the court after the 1936 Coup. The Emperor had no choices, though his great powers was listed in the Meiji Constition. However, he should be responsible to the outbreak of the WWII as he was the head of japan and did not try to stop the brutal war.

If the emperor was guilt, why did not USA kill the emperor?
Japanese imperialist family had ruled Japan for over 2500 years. The emperor was already the spiritual head in the heart of the Japanese. if the US killed him, the anti-US feeling would be intensified.The situation maybe out of control. The war may be till longer.
Japan was also an important base for the anti-communist frontline in the East Asia. The emperor was still useful in the politcal sense. Preventing the arouse of anti-US feeling by not killing the emperor could help USA in controlling Japan in the anti-USSR campaign.
To conclude, though USA was not morale in not imposing the capital punishment to the emperor, she was wise in the political sense.
2007-12-15 11:36 pm
1)發動侵華,日本天皇一定知情,如果日本天皇唔知情就打唔哂8年,
2)我都覺得天皇要判定死刑,個死天皇令我們中國....
3)因為日本唔知錯,所以死口唔認,死日本(仔)
4)有可能,因為40年代開始,日本成人打輸,鬼叫佢走去整美國咩...
5)其實我知日本平民無計劃戰爭,不個唔投,佢唔會投降
參考: 歷史專家
2007-12-14 2:10 am
冇可能...
要天皇受刑 全國日本人一定同你死過..唔會投降
佢地已經比國家教育既忠君愛國方針洗左腦
天皇已經比佢地神化左
所以美國冇要求天皇受審,為求盡快結束戰爭


收錄日期: 2021-04-14 01:15:19
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20071213000051KK02215

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份