"no need" 同" dont need"

2007-10-12 4:54 pm
我聽過人講>>no need<<係錯既,

要用>>dont need<<

咁如果有人問do u want a plastic bag?

咁我答...

i dont need a plastic bag.



no need


最後... >> no need << 係咪錯既呢? 係咪無外國人咁講既呢?

回答 (5)

2007-10-12 5:19 pm
✔ 最佳答案
首先要講,no need與do not need都是不需要的意思,而它們的分別也不在乎是否書寫與口語。
那它們的分別是甚麼?它們的分別是no need的need是作為名詞用,而don't need作動詞用
如:He does not need our help.他不需要我們的幫忙
  I have no need of your help.我不需要你的幫忙
所以,大約你已留意到當用no need時,我們必需在句子中have等動詞,而don't need就毋須加上動詞了。

或許你會問,no need是formal這說法是否你自己的意見,那請你查看yahoo字典也有一例
 We have no need to be afraid of them
而Cambridge Dictionary online就有以下一例: We have no need of your sympathy.

I don't need a plastic bag是沒有錯的,但I have no need of a plastic bag也是正確
但其實當鬼佬問你:Do you want a plastic bag?
你只要說:No, Thank you!或者No, I don't. Thank you!就更簡單,地道。
2007-10-12 5:35 pm
基本上針對呢條問題黎講,'no need' 係英文正式上黎講係唔存在的,佢係屬於中式英文,即由中文直譯成英文,就好似'long time no see'
如果你係外國買野,人地問你'do you want a plastic bag?'

正式書面語可以答:
'No, I don't need a plastic.' <--不過呢種講法會重複左人地講過既野,日常生活對話既話就會顯得好怪.
就好似日常如果人地問你'你今日食左飯未呀?'
你通常會答'食左喇'或'未食呀', 而唔會答'我今日食左飯喇'或'我今日未食飯呀'


如果你答'No need'
人地就會覺得你既英文水平唔係太高,因為文法上本來就係錯的,而且聽落去亦好怪

最好用既日常回答就係
'No thank you' <--呢個回答既有禮貌,又唔會太過書面化,亦唔會重複人地講過既野


題外話(關於no need其他既用法)

'no need' 呢個詞係英文上係存在的,只不過係上面果個問題唔用得,以下我會舉個例子:

There is no need to use a spoon when you are eating a slice of steak.
當你食(牛)排既時候,並唔需要用匙更

There is no need to use a plastic bag if you have an environmental bag.
如果你有環保袋就唔需要膠袋.

以上兩個例子入面'no need' 既意思都係'唔需要',不過一般係用到no need既時候前面都會有there is(there's).

所以如果你入到超市人地問你要唔要膠袋,你只要答'No thank you'黎拒絕,或'Yes please'黎接受就ok了
參考: 自己(英國小朋友)
2007-10-12 5:32 pm
補充

除左hahatse既講法,

no need 係口語

可以放係句子開頭咁用

例如

no need to pay for the toy

no need to sweep the floor 等等
參考: me=]
2007-10-12 5:02 pm
I don't need a plastic bag是書面語
no need就是口語
作文時就用書面語,但平時談話就用口語,沒有那麼累贅ar
參考: 我
2007-10-12 5:00 pm
IDON'T NEED A PLASTIC BAG
我英文唔係咁好,但我無記錯,NO NEED,好似係你對人講
YOU'RE NO NEED TO TAKE A PLASTIC BAG
參考: 我


收錄日期: 2021-04-18 23:31:20
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20071012000051KK00556

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份