Do we have to,have we to...

2007-07-16 11:28 pm
於英文問句中
1)Do(/Does) we(/He,she,they,etc.) have to...?
2)Have(/Has) we(/He/she.they,etc.) to...?

這兩句問句中,哪一句語法才是正確?為什麼?詳解!

回答 (3)

2007-07-17 1:03 am
✔ 最佳答案
只有第一1句是正確的, do we have to ... 中的 have 是動詞, 所以如轉做問題時 要用do 或does, ( if we/I/ you/ they use do; if he/she/it use does).全句解作

我們是否應該...?

而 have we to 是錯的, 因為其中的have 是動詞, 當轉做問題時 動詞是丕能用作倒裝用的
2007-07-17 1:02 am
其實兩個都得
根據第四版牛津高階英漢雙解詞典,在have to的條下,有這樣的講解
”構成否定和疑問句時通常須加do”(注:通常即習慣會加,但不一定加之意)
雖然這樣說法,但在have to的條下,就有以下兩個例子:
(fml 文)Have we to make our own way to the conference?我們必須親自到那裏去開會嗎:
Does she have to stay at home every night?她每天晚上都得待在家裏嗎?
Did you have to pay a fine?你必須交付罰款嗎?
所以,憑以上例子,have...to?和do...have to?都是可用的,但have...to就比較formal一些。
2007-07-17 12:53 am
Only no.1 is correct, we do not use"have we to" in asking questions. It is only used in the rare case of invertion.

For no.1, i suppose the answer will be : we have to.........
we do not use have as the question word in this case instead we use do.


收錄日期: 2021-04-18 22:39:44
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070716000051KK02758

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份