告诉我,错了什么?

👨🏻‍🏫 學術台語言

用戶16228

2007-05-11 9:51 pm

A: We will hire a good band and order a variety of food. Good food and good music are important at such a function.
B: That’s true but we will look at our budget first before planning anything grand.
A: I have came up with a wonderful idea already. To cut costs, we *have had our own college band to perform at our graduation.
*我用(have had)是因為,我認為這個our own college band是一直都存在的,不是將會有的,所以我沒用future tense ,可是也錯了.

更新1:

我可以理解jacaranda所講的道理，但答案是nowai_xy說的那一個。所以，我還是不明白為什麼用will have

更新2:

你們倆都針對perform來用tense，而我是對our own college band來用的。我的問題在哪？

回答 (2)

HaHa

2007-05-16 8:30 pm

✔ 最佳答案

朋友，問題不是出自perform也不是出自our own college band，而是用甚麼時代，而被To cut costs這句獨立不定詞(Absolute Infinitive)，獨立不定詞是表條件的副詞不定詞的一種。獨立不定詞意思上的主詞為說話者，所以不妨用If I(or We)...去思考它即可。
如：To tell the truth, he is a liar=If I tell you the truth, he is a liar.
明白了獨立不定詞的用法後，你就明白To cut costs是表條件的說話，意即如果我們想減低成本：既然減低成本是一句對未來的假設，那麼我們就需要怎樣做也必須是未來的事，所以要用To cut costs, we will have...或To cut costs, we should...或To cut costs, we can...

2007-05-16 12:32:34 補充：
”而是用甚麼時代，而被To cut costs這句獨立不定詞(Absolute Infinitive)...”應為”而是用甚麼時式已被To cut costs這句獨立不定詞(Absolute Infinitive)，

2007-05-16 12:33:17 補充：
所限制了

👍 0 👎 0

Θεοφανια

2007-05-11 9:59 pm

because in the sentence, the meaning should be:
in the coming up performance at graduation, the college band can perform in order to cut costs.
the performance is in the future, which is: HAVE NOT HAPPENED YET, therefore you should use future tense

the correct sentence could be:
I have came up with a wonderful idea already. To cut costs, we can have our own college band to perform at our gradutaion.

👍 0 👎 0

收錄日期: 2021-04-18 22:06:41
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070511000051KK01576

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份