Relatvie Clause 10點~

首先你第一題既答案已經錯左,唔係 The man who I was arguing with is my neighbour .
應該係 The man whom I was arguing with is my neighbour .
而家係你同佢吵架,咁佢就係處於被動,所以要用whom
我舉個例The man is my neighbour. He is a docyor.這句就可以用who
The man who is a doctor is my beighbour.因為句中冇提起其他人，所以唔洗同whom
至於The man I was arguing with who is my neighbour .這句點解唔得,係因為成句既重點係我同佢吵架,而唔係話佢係我鄰居,我地要將句子想講既重點放係前面,如果句子冇明確表示邊句係重點,就可以前後掉轉都冇所謂
第2題,同樣地,個句子既重點係佢地唱得好好聽,而唔係話佢地來自Philippines,有時要分清楚個main clause 係比較難,做多d練習,應該會有幫助

2007-05-07 21:33:13 補充：
其實係而家黎講用who都係得既，但始終都係用whom比較好

要留意：當子句要加插入主句時，用代名詞代替邊個字？

第一句：the man => who；第二句：they (the singers) => who

呢個代名詞一定係放o係主句中同義o個個詞（主／受詞）之後。所以第一句係 The man who I was arguing with ；第二句係 The singers who sing very well 。根本唔能夠任你加插。總之，子句形容o既係邊個詞，就將子句放o係邊個詞後。

2007-05-05 20:12:31 補充：
樓上兩位第一位加左comma，而有comma只係將句子變成非界定（non-defining）子句。第二位睇o既係兩句中邊句係主句。但其實兩位都冇指出你o既問題所在：子句放錯位。

1.The man,who is my neighbour,arguing with him .
2.The singers who come from the Philippines,sing very well.