since : 這兩句有什麼分別 ?

2007-04-22 2:20 am
1) He left the next day and we haven't seen him since.

2) We haven't seen him since he left the next day.

請問 :

一) 以上兩句哪一句是錯的, 還是兩句也是對的 ?

二) 假如兩句是對的, 可否說出意思上有什麼分別, 和哪一句較通用呢 ?

三) 假如有一句是錯的, 可否說出錯在哪裡 ?

謝謝 !

回答 (3)

2007-04-22 3:24 am
✔ 最佳答案
這兩句在文法上都是對的,只不過since在這兩句發揮的功用不同。在第一句裏,since作為副詞,是用來修飾seen[怎樣未曾看見(haven't seen)─自從那時到現在(since)]
如:
ad.(常用於現在完成式或過去完成式)
1. 此後;從那時到現在
She left school three years ago and has worked as a nurse ever since.
她三年前畢業,從那時起便一直當護士。
而第二句的since是作為一個連接詞用,如:
conj.
1. (常用於現在完成式或過去完成式)自...以來,從...至今
It's been ten years since they married.
他們結婚到現在已經十年了。
She has been living a hard life since her husband died.
自從丈夫死後,她一直過著艱苦的生活。

所以,兩句都對,只不過since在兩句中功用不同。

2007-04-22 08:06:49 補充:
你這兩句在意思上分別並不大,第一句是1) He left the next day and we haven't seen him since.(他隔天便離開了,此後我們再沒有見過他)2) We haven't seen him since he left the next day.(自從他隔天離開後,我們便再沒有見過他)這兩句不但在意思上相近,這兩種寫法也有很多人用。
2007-04-22 2:39 am
一)
1)錯
2)對

三)
第一句應該寫作:"He left the next day and we haven't seen him since then."
2007-04-22 2:28 am
1) He left the next day and we haven't seen him since.

2) We haven't seen him since he left the next day.

請問 :

一) 以上兩句哪一句是錯的, 還是兩句也是對的 ?
1)錯
2)對

二) 假如兩句是對的, 可否說出意思上有什麼分別, 和哪一句較通用呢 ?
既然1係錯,咁就唔用
意思上一樣,係文法錯


三) 假如有一句是錯的, 可否說出錯在哪裡 ?
1) He left the next day and we haven't seen him since
since應放中間,and先講所以...再講點解
so係We haven't seen him since he left the next day


收錄日期: 2021-04-20 18:33:06
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070421000051KK03885

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份