練琴可以進步...但唔練係咪等於唔進步呢?

I would like to raise a question that what kind of improvement are you asking? Technical improvement or Musical improvement?

I am sure that if you refuse to practise for a long time, you will definitely make no improvement on your techniques. But, if you spend this time to keep in touch with different types of music, study about different composers and their works, gain life experience etc., this may greatly help your performing quality in music. You may have a deeper feeling about the pieces. For example, the Pathetique Sonata by Beethoven: if you ask a child with a very high standard of techniques to play that, his performance may be worse than a adult player of a lower technical standard, because the adult player has more experience in life. He knew what is the actual feeling of the "Pathetique" feeling, deeply unhappy etc.

You may find that if you experience more in you daily life and refuse to parctise for a time, although you will find that you technical level is not that good, you find your playing definitely different than before.

So, it depends on what sort of improvement are you looking for!

2007-04-09 16:08:03 補充：
the point I emphasise is that we look for both technical and musical fluency in piano playing. You may spend much time practise in front of your piano, but that doeesn't mean that you must have reached a high standard both technically and musically.

唔練琴都可以進步, 個人認為係有可能的! 但視乎你既琴藝去到邊個地步...

譬如你只係初級既學生, 底子未夠好, 基本既指法都未熟練, 係咁既情況下, 唔練琴的話只會令你已經唔太好既琴藝退步.

而如果你已經有一定既琴藝, 就有可能去到一D所謂既 "樽頸位" , 練極都進步唔到, 練極都棘住棘住咁. 此時此刻如果識得停一停, 放膽唔練一陣, 反而會有更好既效果... 需知道, 要彈好一首歌, 除左要有相當既琴技外, 你係心理上對個首歌, 對個琴, 甚至對音樂哩樣野既感通都好緊要, 坐低死練琴, 等如生硬地練技術, 對心理成長毫無幫助. 更可能會令你個人對琴對音樂 "莫" 左.

如果你已經有番咁上下技術, 就真係可以試下俾自己一個 "緩衝期" , 完全唔練琴, 玩下其他樂器, 聽多D唔同既音樂, 睇下D作曲家既故事, 聽下其他人演奏, refresh下個人, 係咁既情況下, 唔練都幾個月再彈番會都有進步!

我識...
依家有7級
我記得..有幾個月因為考試所以冇練到
之後練番...問頭果陣..有小小蠢動..之後就好似平時拉得咁好聽囉
其實我平時冇咩點練小提琴
不過我對小提琴有好大興趣
其實練咩都好最重要有興趣...就算你冇練好奈..
你本身有興趣..就自自然會加強你既學習速度
姐係如果你本身對果樣野冇興趣..你點練都好..都唔會達到自己既最好水準
所以我同意你既講法...只要有興趣..就算唔係成日練...都會有進步

2007-04-09 07:28:37 補充：
我識拉小提琴