I like to use lancome's BI-FACIL beacuse it is very easy to remove the makeup and also unexpensive.
Non Greasy Instant Cleanser Sensitive Eyes
This double-phase liquid is as fresh as water, yet removes even waterproof eye makeup. Activates when shaken to gently whisk away eye makeup, while conditioning and refreshing the skin.
Ideal for sensitive skin and contact lens wearers. Leaves eyes feeling cool and relaxed, with no oily residue.