Biology 生物研究 bio 人請進, 關於電影[異形2 Aliens] [***20分***]

2007-03-03 8:42 pm
呢個係一個討論, 想知大家点睇.

***請用自己文字作答***

前晚睇返電影 異形2 Aliens, 諗起一個問題 - 如果你有睇過是但一部異形(但第2集最清楚) 都會知道啲異形係由蛋生, 變成八隻脚嘅怪物 (可以話係幼蟲), 然後搵一個生物 (稱之為 host, 可以係人, 狗 (Alien 3), 甚至 Predator (AvP) 都得) 植一個胚胎入去. 冇幾耐隻幼蟲會死亡, 但隨之o係個 host 個肚度走一隻成蟲異形出嚟...

無疑D alien 係一個完美嘅捕獵者. 先別論佢哋個 social structure 同 hierarchy 係点, o係 reprodutive biology 嘅角度嚟睇, 你覺得佢哋呢個 life cycle 可唔可行, 係咪 efficient 呢? 請簡單解釋 (我心入面有一個答案, 但唔想打出嚟 bias 啲 result). 喔, 最好講埋自己学歷, 蘇蘇quali 嘻嘻...

***請唔好 copy and paste 異形 嘅電影介紹俾我!!*** *_*

唔該晒!! ^_^

回答 (1)

2007-03-06 11:20 am
✔ 最佳答案
I type better in English so may I answer in English first? I did not only copy and paste. I just paste some pictures to help explaining things I typed myself. I will look at this problem in a comparative anatomy perspective.
Hypothesis 1: It's a Diplobiontic creature
Diplontic life cycle
If you know about the life cycle of animals and plants there are diploid stages (2n) and haploid stages (1n). Diploid in human start as an embryo, through childhood into adult. Haploid(1n) stage is very short, only sperm and egg(gametes).

圖片參考:http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/23/Gametic_meiosis.png/250px-Gametic_meiosis.png

Haplontic life cycle
In some animals like jelly fish, the body of the adult animal is actually 1n. So female and male jelly fish are the same genetic makeup with the gametes (sperm and egg). The 2n stage (zygote) is very short.

圖片參考:http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/7f/Zygotic_meiosis.png/250px-Zygotic_meiosis.png

Diplobiontic life cycle
And there is a third type of life cycle that the 1n and 2n stages are all obvious. These are more common in plants called algae and bryophyte (fern allies). They grow one body that is 1n, and another body that is 2n. Sometimes this 2n is a parasite on its own 1n parent.

圖片參考:http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/8/86/Sporic_meiosis.png/250px-Sporic_meiosis.png

So back to your story, your alien may be a 1n (gametophyte) stage where you say 幼蟲, and after it has mated and made a 2n (sporophyte) where you say 成蟲. It is a very different looking animal and their relationship is not parent and child. It's something in between.
Hypothesis 2: It's a parasitic creature that needs an intermediate host to mature
This example is the Chinese Liver Fluke. The eggs are passed out into the water, eaten by snail. Inside the snail it grow into the next stage, bursted out the snail shell, and infect a fish by digging into its muscles. When human eat the fish it completes the lifecycle by infecting the intestine, and finally make its way into the liver.

圖片參考:http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/1f/Clonorchis_LifeCycle.gif/280px-Clonorchis_LifeCycle.gif

So in your story, human is just one more host to complete this complex lifecycle. Considering your alien only needs one host (human) instead of three (liver fluke), that's a simple lifecycle indeed.
My choice and why:
I think you probably would like the Hypothesis 2 because it is what you describe with chinese words like 幼蟲, 成蟲. And very likely the novelist/movie makers got the Alien idea from these parasitic life cycle too. But personally I like the Hypothesis 1 because it is exotic. Not a lot of people are aware of Diplobiontic creatures, and people keep arguing in 知識+ about if sperms and eggs are animals. So this might as well be your next discussion topic!
參考: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biological_life_cycle; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clonorchis_sinensis; a bit from AL Biology, a bit from comparative anatomy, a bit from my teaching experience and a bit from my opinions


收錄日期: 2021-04-30 00:00:10
原文連結 [永久失效]:
http://hk.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/question?qid=7007030301723

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份