✔ 最佳答案
Excellent question, one of the very few here that deserves an answer. In the last 27 years, because of work requirements and personal comfort, I have never owned a dog that was NOT trained in the art of protection. My personal favorite all time breed is the malinois with a second place going to the bouvier and third going to a shepherd. None of these dogs are domistic dogs by the way, I import all of mine from Europe.I feel that after having imported, trained and deployed with hundreds of dogs in the last 27 years, I have a pretty good idea of what they can and cannot offer in terms of protection and security. For a pesonal protection dog, I prefer a female, but a TOP quality female that is almost as hard as a male without all the accompanying stupidity that goes with a male. Females tend to be more tractable and more calm then males and are able to perform better in a home environment. Males tend to do better in the sports arena and the real world of the street. I tend to think that the same dog that goes with me to work every day, will protect me at home just as well, so there is no need to have 2 dogs performing the same function. Dogs that are formally trained in protection are more confident in their environment and are not as easily bothered as "natural" protection dogs. They are for sure more dependable and predictable then a dog that has not been trained. I cannot stand to read or hear the stupidity of some comments that go "my dog will protect me to death" and he is never been trained. It is hard enough to find a dog that will have the ability to be trained for protection, never mond what one will do "naturally" It will run away from a strong threat and you can take that to the bank. The best dogs that I have seen and the nicest ones to be around, are older police dogs that have worked the street for years and have had numerous apprehensions, they look at you with such disdain and have no need to demonstrate anything because experience taught them that they can kick your butt anytime they want, that makes them safe. Having a dog that was trained in engaging a human is a responsibility that shouls not be taken lightly. I, personally, will never own a dog that was not FORMALLY trained in protection.