Allergic to Biotherm and Shiseido, need help?

I don't wear make up most of time, but I do need in some occassions (about once a month). I generally used the cheaper one where I could get in Target such as L'real and Neutrogena.

However, recently I wanted to go more high quaility and tried Shiseido and Biotherm. I guess these are the 2 bigger brands for younger people and cheaper, too.

I found I am allergic to both brands. I could use nothing in Shiseido except the sunblock. I just tried the Biotherm Matte Souffle Powdery Mattifying Mousse Foundation and it was a nightmare. Redded face and itchy!

I am pretty pissed off, so is there any recommendation which brand I should try? Is there any ingredient that these 2 have in common? I cannot waste any more money on this. Please help. Thanks.