Does who calling? 文法有錯嗎?

絕對錯!!!!

因為who 係唔應該放在does後面,所以
你可以說...

who did called?

who does called?

Did anyone call?

who is calling?

Who did called, who does called 都是錯的! Did 和 does 只會與 infinitive 一齊用, 唔會 did / does + p.p. 的!

若是你跟在電話線另一方的人提問，你可以問：
Who is this?
Who is calling?
May I know who is calling?
May I know whom I am speaking with?
May I know with whom I am speaking?

若你是聽到電話響，但有他人已接聽了，你可以問：
(接聽者仍在電話上）
Who is calling?
Who is on the other side?
(接聽者已掛了線）
Who called?

====
Who was calling? 不行，因為你不會是說一件在過去在發生的事情。
Who is calling you? 可以，但是說話者「八卦」，去問聽話者誰打電話給他
Who did called? 不行，文法錯誤。
Who does called?同樣文法錯誤。
Did anyone call? 文法正確，不過這句是問有沒有人打過電話來。
Who calls? 不行，文法錯誤，因為call一就是現在進行式，一就是過去式。


2007-01-05 12:50:04 補充：
首兩句的文法都是錯的

of caz wrong la!

who calls?
who is calling?
who's speaking?

Who is calling you?

Who was calling?