基督徒會否咀咒人, 這是否教唆他人自殺???????

2006-12-24 10:27 pm
http://hk.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/?link=evaluation_list&qid=7006121503281

(~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?)

你去死!
你試下做耶穌吖,笨!
一定係發問者有問題先選你
而家天主都寬恕你,你唔多謝佢,重要鬧佢!
咁差!


(~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?) 很不滿我所選的答案然後留言叫我去死....如果我真係去死....咁他是否教唆他人自殺???

我沒有檢舉此留言....不過我覺得實有基督徒咁做啦, 但原因一定不是覺得(~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?)唔啱, 而係見到我出問題, 就要立即毀屍滅跡!!! 哈哈~!


(~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?) 很不滿我所選的答案然後留言叫我去死....如果我真係去死....咁他是否教唆他人自殺???
更新1:

如果答題者真係去死....咁他是否教唆他人自殺???

回答 (8)

2006-12-25 5:59 am
✔ 最佳答案
I don't know who (~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?) is but if s/her left u a message [你去死!], regardless if s/he is a Christian or not, that's just rude and it's an unacceptable behavior.

There are Christians who do all kinds of bad things (bad testimony like a pastor sexually harrasted a girl in church...) but u see non-Christians commit the crime in the same nature too so we can see that ppl do bad things regardless if they are Christian or not. So the fact that they being Christians does not take part in the crime they committed.

As we have been saying, Christian are just normal human being and not everything they do is based on their faith. I do not believe that the act of leaving u such message is because (~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?) is a Christian. Responding is in such way is unbiblical (Proverbs 25:8) There are many Christians on this planet and I don't know how many Christians had read ur particular posting but apparently u only told us that (~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?) reacted in that sense. How often does this occur to u? I think it is fair to say that this is one single inccident. It is not a massive common behavior among Christians.

Also, I am sure that there are Christians who did great things for the society. During SARS, Doctor Joanna Tsz died because she wanted to save lives using her profession. It wasn't a secret that she was a Christian. Do every Christians do great things like she did? No. Are non-Christians incapable doing great things like that because they are not Christian? Of course not! That's why we should not make stereotypes of any groups; it is unfair.

Anyway, I am sorry to hear what u have gone through. It was bad. But 叫你去死 is more of a figure of speech which serves linguistic function commonly shared among Cantonese speakers so please do not take that personally and go to die for real. In such discourse, 叫你去死 expresses (~~夜神月^ ^@為甚麼沒有人答我問題?)'s anger toward ur response. It was not good vocab to use though so ppl should avoid using it.

2006-12-24 22:03:25 補充:
In Canada we have something called Charter of Rights and Freedoms where your freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication is guaranteed.

2006-12-24 22:06:08 補充:
As a Canadian, I found 夜神月's comment inappropriate because it violates ur freedom of opinion (in choosing ur answer)So in this case I am on ur side.
2007-01-05 7:00 pm
凡 事 包 容 . 凡 事 相 信 . 凡 事 盼 望 . 凡 事 忍 耐 。 愛 是 永 不 止 息
哥 林 多 前 書 十 三 章 7 - 8節
2006-12-31 1:54 am
根據聖經,上帝寛容抵擋祂的人,是希望他們悔改。

抵擋上帝的人一直將上帝的慈愛當作放縱的藉口,不去認識造物主。 可是, 凡事都有定期,寛容始終會有盡頭的一天,報應和審判會接踵而來。

抵擋上帝的人的結局就是在今世會得到報應,末日審判時會受刑罰。

惟有認罪悔改,接受主耶穌為救主,成為基督徒,才可改變這結局。
2006-12-27 8:14 am
基督徒會否這樣做,就要看看當時人是怎樣,但聖經話逼迫你們的,要給他們祝福;只要祝福,不可咒詛。
2006-12-26 3:13 am
只憑一句魯莽之言,sin兄唔好當真。

基督徒都有唔同性格,亦有基督徒是很火爆的。

若基督徒教唆他人自殺,當然是基督徒做錯了。
但若你真的走去自殺,就是你的錯。

事情,要整完整地去睇,為何「夜神月」會咁火爆?是否之前受了甚人挑釁所至呢?

以我分析,事緣是:提問者的和發問者的內容,其實都不能反映基督教真實的一面。所以「夜神月」看見,便發火,好正常,可以理解,你唔會expect d基督徒會稱讚你吧。

算吧啦,不必當真,樓主公開問這問題都係講下笑姐。

2006-12-29 16:31:21 補充:
同意樓主所講的。

基督徒真的要僅慎言行,以免得罪別人失見證之餘,還令神的名蒙羞。

有時反對者的聲音,並不是毫無道理,若他們說得有理,我都會接納。
2006-12-24 10:56 pm
會有一D基督徒詛咒人去死。
但呢D並唔係教會教義。
所以詛咒人去死個個。查實等同犯最。
如果對方因此而自殺。佢個後果係會好慘架。
因為佢--->引人犯最(自殺)。

2006-12-24 20:56:52 補充:
順理成章如果有人以為耶穌基督的救恩可以保護自己而任意犯最的話。咁呢個人肯定未得救。
2006-12-24 10:36 pm
督徒不會咀咒人
2006-12-24 10:31 pm
基督徒會否咀咒人是其自由

但基督徒不應該咀咒他人

但從上例子:

"你去死" 這句應該屬一句戲言.

收錄日期: 2021-04-23 19:11:15
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061224000051KK01959

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份