除法的問題

2006-12-20 7:07 am
這是一道文字題:9除3等於多少?我答:3除以9等於3份1,老師說我錯了,應該是9除以3等於3.但我小學學除法(我依家讀中一),老師千叮萬囑要我們留意文字題中的是"除"還是"除以",如果是"除"的話,在除字前面的字就是除數,後面的是被除數.如果是"除以"就按順序.究竟誰對誰錯,誰是誰非?
P.S.我是在內地讀小學的.

回答 (4)

2006-12-20 10:05 am
✔ 最佳答案
9 ÷ 3 = 3 (9是被除數, 3是除數)
正確中文讀法 是 9 除以3等如3
正確英文讀法 是 9 divided by 3 equal to 3

讀成 9除3 或 9 divide 3 , 依正確的中/英文的文字意思, 答案都是3分1

如 9 ÷ 3 讀成 9除3 或 9 divide 3, 祇是貪方便, 一般平常生活對話, 尚可接受, 但在教學及知識層面(如出版界)上當然是絕不可以接受及通融。對就是對, 錯就要改,你老師所說完全是對的。

同樣道理, 9 - 3 亦是應讀成 9減以3
如讀成 9 減 3, 答案會變成 負6

在內地的教學方式, 我就不清楚了
參考: 靠自己
2006-12-20 4:46 pm
9 除以3等如3
9 is divided by 3 equal to 3

9除3 或 9 divides 3......... both these two statements are not used in practice because the statements IMPLICITLY imply that " 3 is divisible by 9 " .

I am totally agreed with kowloondicky answer. In order to avoid ambiguity, this is why definitions must be declared before doing any math.

Your answer is exactly right. However, there are very often typing and printing mistakes in the books today. You should ask your teacher to clarify the question if you are confused with the wording of the question.
2006-12-20 7:12 am
9除3=3除以9=3份1, 不知道你老師為什麼說你錯.
2006-12-20 7:11 am
你同條佢問ge都唔岩~
9除除除除除除除除除除除除除除除3等於多少
我答:3除以以以以以以以以以以以以以以9等於3份1


收錄日期: 2021-04-12 18:21:40
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061219000051KK04618

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份