點解神要一開始就俾有d 人天生就有殘障, 咁樣令個d人痛苦.

2006-12-04 3:15 pm
希望有人可以解答到.
更新1:

又假設自己係個種人~又會又有d 咩反應同埋感受呢?

更新2:

同埋如果bible 入面有寫既話~~又係第幾章可以搵到呀??

回答 (9)

2006-12-11 1:25 am
我認同你!

世界上根本沒有所謂耶和華這種神!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2006-12-05 11:20 pm
是因為人類的共同始祖亞當及夏娃犯了反抗上帝的罪,
因而失去了上帝的保護,
而成了不完美的人,
亞當也在930歲的高齡下死去,
他在世時沒有辦法將完美而受上帝保護的基因遺傳給他的後代,
所以他的後代都是不完美的,
直到現今,
人類已演化了六千多年,
不完美的祖先與不完美的祖先交合,
產生了更不完美的後代,
所以有很多人在出生前已遺傳到了很不完美的基因,
因而先天就有了遺傳病或殘疾.
不過聖經提出了一個很好的希望,
在以賽亞書第35章,
它談到未來上帝要醫治好一切有殘疾的人,
到時就不會再有人生病或衰老或死亡了.
2006-12-05 11:57 am
神係為左佢地好
唔好問點解,因為神既愛世人係唔明白既
以有限既智慧去解神無限既愛點解都解唔通
話唔定上到天常重有大把你受,總知就為你好啦
請相信神
2006-12-05 9:07 am
這個問題,背後有一套價值觀,
就是:不殘障的人比較快樂、不殘障的人比較幸福。人的快樂和幸福和他的能力有關,沒有能力或能力較低的人比較痛苦。

但神看我們就不想這樣,又或者,我們看我們都不要這樣。神看我們每一個都很寶貝,很珍貴。我們也當看自己是很珍貴的。

我認為,人是否幸福和痛苦,是在乎人是否被關心、被愛,並且是否懂得愛自己。
我的母校有個女仔,佢冇咗隻手,但佢每次游泳比賽都拿冠軍(同番其他健全的人比賽),
(佢唔係基督徒,我唔係想sell話信耶穌勁d)。佢個人好開朗,令週圍的人很舒服和開心。

殘障人之所有有覺得痛苦的,除了身體冇其他人咁叻,最大的痛苦是來自別人的白眼。但如果我們改變一下心態,唔係去歧視佢哋,而係去照顧佢哋、關心佢哋,咁呢個世界就好唔同。

人習慣用一些物質價值去看人,才令這個世界好多唔開心事。不過我覺得香港在關懷殘障人方面做得算不錯了。

一個故事,不是真人真事,但個精神值得學習。

從前有個哥哥,佢係天才,好有智慧。他的弟弟卻是弱智的。

人們問神說:為何你咁唔公平,你俾哥哥咁有智慧,你卻造弟弟咁蠢。
神回答說:我送給哥哥一份禮物,就是聰明智慧。我送給弟弟一份禮物,就是一個很愛護和照顧他的哥哥。

神的心意就是這樣。神用身體各部份來比喻我們(見哥林多前書):我們俊美的肢體,自然用不著裝飾,但神配搭這身子,把加陪的體面加給那有缺欠的肢體......總要肢體彼此相顧。
2006-12-05 6:12 am
我可以試下解答你既問題既....
其實神係每一個人既生命裡都有著佢自己既旨意....
有d人一開始有殘障....係神放在他生命裡一個既試驗.....
神很想這個人學習去憑著衪的能力去得勝這個病....
衪更想藉著醫治這個人...讓其他人也看到衪的大能大力...
神要這個人一出生就有缺陷...是因為衪想這個人在病中也能榮耀和學習倚靠衪^^
如果你係那個人....要有大信心神是會醫治你的....你要記著神是愛....在bible中....jesus連一個有了12年血漏病的婦人也都醫治....就是因為那婦人的信心....所以不應灰心!!!
2006-12-04 8:14 pm
First of all, I am sorry but I totally disagree with the first response.
"如果沒有災難﹐ 人不會需要神" is simply not true. First you have to understand the relationship between human and God. God is our "heavenly Father". What is the relationship between your parent and you? Moreover, when would you not need your parents? I think anyone who enjoys a healthy relationship with their parents would never say that "I don't need my parent". And of course, if you don't see God as your Father, those questions that I proposed would not be relevant. But I can tell you that in Christianity, God is the "heavenly Father" of people. And since this question is asked under the context of Christianity, of course the answer has to be from the point of view of Christian. I hope this makes sense.

Anyways, back to the question posted. A higly relevant passage from the Bible would be John 9:1-11. Please do not take this passage out of context however. Jesus was asked, "whose sin caused this man to be born blind --- his own sin or his parents' sin?" Jesus replied, "It is not this man's sin or his parents' sin that made him be blind. This man was born blind so that God's power could be shown in him." Please do not take this wrong. God doesn't have to make people miserable to make Himself seems "more powerful". The fact that He created the Earth already shows how powerful He is. God doesn't have to make someone disabled so that people have to "beg" for mercy to show that He is a loving God. The fact that Jesus Christ became a human, lived among us and died for us already shows how much God loves us. God is love and God is power. He doesn't have to do things to "prove" he has those qualities because He simply IS.

Now let's look at the question --- "點解神要一開始就俾有d 人天生就有殘障, 咁樣令個d人痛苦". The first assumption here is people who has disability (殘障) must be suffered from a "painful" life. The second assumption is that God assigns certain people to be born disabled.
Let's deal with the first assumption first. I do not think that people who has disability has to be suffering. There are many many testimonies Christians as well as non-Christian living an abundent life even with their physically disability. Physically illness does not make a person also suffer from mentally illness. People can be sick yet happy. These two things can co-exist. 2nd, our God is a God who allows us to have difficulties because we became stronger by overcoming our challenges. I do not think anyone on this planet has an "absolutely perfect" life. Some people may "suffer" from physical illness, some may suffer from relationship problems... People can only be "better" if they "become better".
Physically difficulties is a problem of many many many other problems that we have. It is sure that people who is able to overcome their problems would feel much better about themselves.
The best person to ask would be those who has physically disability. Here is a link to an interview: http://video.google.ca/videoplay?docid=-8950821040853832747&q=sobem
" 天生失去雙手的盧佩鏞,從來沒怨天尤人,反而奮力闖出自己的路,成為香港著名的口足畫家,以腳畫出人生色彩,一向堅毅的她,終於遇上了生命中最大的挑戰---爸爸的離世⋯" TV0735 - 足本色彩 (sobem video)

I hope this helps.

God bless.

2006-12-04 13:53:59 補充:
http://video.google.ca/videoplay?docid=-1975891019115823299&q=sobemTV0835 - 因禍得福 (Another testimony from SOBEM) 一場交通意外,為大好青年林衍廷帶來了終生的殘障,除卻肉體受到極度痛苦之外,亦為家庭添上深切的哀愁。然而這個被人視為噩夢開始的咒詛,竟是林家的一份祝福。意外喚醒了人的自我陶醉,傷殘搗破了人與人之間的冷漠,神的大愛與大能,更成為了一家常常喜樂,勇敢面對明天的根源。
參考: The Holy Bible, SOBEM
2006-12-04 7:03 pm
我都諗過同樣的問題,但我都係唔明白.
但睇左下面一篇文章後,使我明白多左.
希望呢篇文章都幫到你la^v^

文章內容
一個黑人和上帝對話
上帝啊!請告訴我為什麼我這麼黑﹖
你皮膚黑才能抵抗非洲炎熱的太陽。上帝說。
 
那麼,上帝,為什麼我的頭髮又短又捲﹖
這樣你才不會在非洲炎熱的天氣下流汗。
 
上帝,那麼為什麼我的腳這麼大﹖
這樣你就比較容易從非洲的猛獸口中逃生。
請告訴我上帝,那我為什麼生在香港﹖

 
你曾經觀察過嗎﹖
 
人們總是對於那些不滿意的事問為什麼,
對於喜歡的,滿意的事從來不問為什麼﹖
 
你曾質疑過為什麼你生下來就好手好腳嗎﹖
你會懷疑說周遭為什麼有這麼多美好的事物﹖
 
 
為什麼你能平安地活到現在嗎﹖
 
對於那些幸福與美好的事,人們從不會去懷疑。
不可否認,祂的確經常讓人失望。
 
也許
祂沒有給你一份你想要的工作,
沒有給你夢想的身材,
沒有給你會中獎的號碼,
 
祂甚至剝奪了你的健康,
奪走了你喜歡的東西和所愛的人;
 
但祂會這樣做,還是為了你好,
這點必須等到事過境遷,
等你夠成熟了你才會懂。
 
祂不在乎你會怎麼想,也不在乎你的抱怨,
因為這不是祂關切的。
 
祂在乎的是你,是你的成長,
你的覺知、你對人生的體會,
在乎的是如何幫你成為「更好的你」。
 
將失望(disappointment)的第一個字母「D」拿掉,換成「H」。
失望就變成了上帝的指示(His appointment)。
 
所以說任何發生在你身上的事都是好的。
 
如果祂經常挫折你、考驗你,
那是祂想知你是否能擔任重任;
 
如果祂沒能滿足你的期望,
那只不過是意味著你的期望是錯的。
 

祂讓你失敗,是為了讓你學到謙卑;
讓你受騙,是為了增長你的智慧;
 
讓你受傷害,是為了使你更堅強;
讓你受委屈,是為了砥礪你的人格;
 
讓你受打擊,是為了提醒你的缺點;
讓你失去,是為了教你懂得珍惜;
 
讓你痛苦,是為了讓你醒覺;
讓你絆倒,是為了強化你的雙腿。
 
現實即使是殘酷,
 
但是上天總是慈悲的,
祂總是為你好
 
被祂原諒不一定足夠
有時你也得學習原諒自己
2006-12-04 5:05 pm
其實我自己都唔明 但我覺得神並沒有允許我們會有健康的身體 相反神就允許我們有永生
我不懂說 只是我覺得 人太無知 我們都不太明白神做事的目的
參考: 自己
2006-12-04 3:33 pm
因為神想借助依D 人黎顯出佢 既 " 愛 "。 如果沒有災難﹐ 人不會需要神。 人會在災難中團結﹐ 會因為災難而求神庇祐﹑ 看顧。 而這些不幸被選上做 " 犧牲品 " 既人﹐ 或者神會在佢生命中某個地方作出補賞﹐ 或在他死後賜與天堂。

2006-12-04 07:39:28 補充:
好似當正常人看見殘障或不幸個陣﹐ 可能會去感謝神無將如此災禍降落在自己身上。


收錄日期: 2021-04-22 23:23:40
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061204000051KK00548

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份