香港應唔應該獨立好?

2006-10-26 7:18 pm
香港獨立左, 會有咩好處 同 壞處

回答 (5)

2006-10-26 7:32 pm
✔ 最佳答案
Advantage:
Hong Kong people can have larger freedom.
People can decide their own policies towards different nations and involve in the nationwide conferences like the United Nation.

Disadvantage:
1. Hong Kong is lack of natural resources, if the relationship with the neighboring country turns worse, daily living of citizens are affected.
2.After independent, Hong Kong people have to handle the nation defence themselves and it involve large amount of money, technology and manpower.
3. Hong Kong has no fortified sites to defend, and it has limited land for development. It seems to be impossible for Hong Kong to maintain a missile site and other military services.
4. Hong Kong is a little place and it has limited influence in World Affairs, the concerns of citizens could possibly be ignored.
2006-10-28 1:57 am
回歸已經十年, 唔好想壞腦. 你肯我都唔肯,
全民投票你一定輸晒.
台灣或者有機會博一博.
2006-10-26 9:11 pm
no.
HK should be British colony forever !
British ruling is the BEST! HK people can make money & live very stable
Hk people dont want to take risk . we cannot afford our own army (no one is willing to join HK army .)
China is so big and strong . HK cannot fight against it .
參考: me
2006-10-26 7:36 pm
好處:
香港現時的政制發展,多受中共制肘,獨立左後可以不受限制。
經濟上,某些與中共關係特別密切的商人會分多一點餅仔,獨立後可更體現社會公平。
社會上亦有很多人因與中共的關係而可以上位,獨立後可更體現社會公平。
在外交上,香港獨立後可以有更大的獨立性,依家基本上係依大陸的方針造事。

懷處:
大陸會一個原子彈射爆香港。
就算唔射爆香港都會派解放軍落來。
就算唔攻落來經濟上封鎖香港, 香港將會無水飲,無菜食,重要無得食長城牌午餐肉。
香港經濟會仆直,淨係無得買工商銀行都夠阿順嫂喊三日。
外交上無大陸照,佢亦會唔俾外國同香港建交,變左好似台灣咁,淨係可以俾錢然後同d個名好長既國家建交。
香港很多人的民族感情受到嚴重損害,例如林睡瑞麟有機會跳樓自殺。(當然親中不同於親中共,什至更可以因愛護中國文化而反中共,但香港事實上有很多人把民族感情投放於中共上)

只想到這麼多
2006-10-26 7:34 pm
好處:
1)獨立自主
2)世界地位提升

壞處:
1)須籌備軍費等開支
2)會出現與中國的不正常關係
3)本身不能自給自足,大部份必需品都須進口
4)香港賴以為生的經濟因與中國的關係而被受影響
5)香港人沒有民族意識,很難同甘同苦
6)...

收錄日期: 2021-04-12 17:45:52
原文連結 [永久失效]:
https://hk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061026000051KK00896

檢視 Wayback Machine 備份